PL 54 · cols. 441–446
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermon LXXXVIII
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 441–446
Sermon LXXXVIII
(a) ‹ad renovandum statum› · printed under col 441
Prima editio et unus cod. Vat., felicitatis.
The first edition and one Vatican ms., felicitatis.
(b) ‹Convertimini ad me› · printed under col 441
Ms., Venet., ex toto; et paulo post scindite pro disrumpite in prima editione et in mss. collect. 3 et 4.
The Venice ms., ex toto; and a little after, scindite for disrumpite in the first edition and in the mss. of collections 3 and 4.
(c) ‹hujus curationis remedia› · printed under col 441
Codex Venet. etiam a nobis necessariae praedicantur.
The Venice ms., etiam a nobis necessariae praedicantur.
(d) ‹ut in observantia› · printed under col 441
Prima editio, satisfactionis.
The first edition, satisfactionis.
(e) ‹Divinarum› · printed under col 441
Autem pro namque melius reposuimus ex ms. Veneto.
We have, better, put back autem for namque from the Venice ms.
(f), (g), (h), (i) printed under col 441 but called in col 442, set in n442
SYNOPSIS. — I. Jejunia, sine quibus antiquis justitia Dei non est placata, nobis quoque esse necessaria. — II. Multo potentiora esse quando ab omnibus simul fidelibus celebrantur. — III. Debere se quemque interdum curis subtrahere, ut saluti suae intentius vacet. Unitas orationis quam potens sit. — IV. Plurimum valere apud Deum consensum bonorum. Animum, non censum in eleemosynis pensari. — V. Quemque debere pro facultate sua eleemosynas erogare sine diffidentia.
SYNOPSIS. — I. That fasts, without which the justice of God was not appeased for the ancients, are necessary for us also. — II. That they are much more powerful when they are celebrated by all the faithful together. — III. That each one ought at times to withdraw himself from cares, so as to give himself more intently to his salvation. How powerful the unity of prayer is. — IV. That the agreement of good men avails very much with God. That in almsgiving the mind, not the means, is weighed. — V. That each one ought to bestow alms according to his means, without distrust.
(f) ‹populus, quando› · printed under col 441
Idem cod. Venet., unitate.
The same Venice ms., unitate.
(g) ‹ab opere› · printed under col 441
Vocem pietatis a Quesnello deletam restituimus ex omnibus editis nostrisque codicibus.
We have restored the word pietatis, deleted by Quesnel, from all the printed editions and our mss.
(h) ‹Ad hujus ergo invictae› · printed under col 441
Editi ante Quesnellum cum mss. collect. posteriorum et Lectionar. Veneto, pietatis. Sed melius ille, unitatis; nam refertur ad unitatem sanctae obedientiae, quae praecedenti capite memoratur, cuique insistitur initio cap. 5.
The editions before Quesnel, with the mss. of the later collections and the Venice Lectionary, pietatis. But he [reads] better, unitatis; for it refers to the unity of holy obedience, which is mentioned in the preceding chapter and is dwelt on at the beginning of ch. 5.
(i) ‹per humanam fragilitatem› · printed under col 441, continued under col 442
Ms. Vat. collect. 5, a supernis recedimus, deletis vocibus, in terrena. Alius Vat. collect. 4, decidimus, pro recidimus.
The Vatican ms. of collection 5, a supernis recedimus, the words in terrena being deleted. Another Vatican [ms.] of collection 4, decidimus, for recidimus.
(j) ‹offendimus omnes (Jacob III, 2).› · printed under col 442
Particula et, quam Quesnellus delevit, ex omnibus editis et nostris codd. revocavimus.
The particle et, which Quesnel deleted, we have restored from all the printed editions and our mss.
(k) ‹impendio majore deleri.› · printed under col 442
Prima editio et cod. Bon., Plenissima autem est peccatorum abolitio.
The first edition and the Bon. ms., Plenissima autem est peccatorum abolitio.
(l) ‹duorum vel trium› · printed under col 442
Ita ms. Venet., duo Vatt. et prima editio. Al., sanctorum pio consensui.
So the Venice ms., two Vatican [mss.] and the first edition. Others, sanctorum pio consensui.
(m) ‹Magnum est› · printed under col 442
Restituimus lectionem editorum ante Quesnellum, quam omnes nostri codices praeferunt. Quesnellus nihil indicans, et in conspectu Domini, dilectissimi, valde pretiosum.
We have restored the reading of the editions before Quesnel, which all our mss. present. Quesnel, indicating nothing, et in conspectu Domini, dilectissimi, valde pretiosum.
(n) ‹eodem cooperantur affectu; cum› · printed under col 442
Sic ex nostris mss. et editis ante Quesnellum, apud quem, in declinando a malo, ac faciendo bonum.
So from our mss. and the editions before Quesnel, in whom [we read] in declinando a malo, ac faciendo bonum.
(o) ‹par cunctorum› · printed under col 442
Mss. Corb. et Vict. Quesnelli, una substantia.
Quesnel's Corbie and Saint-Victor mss., una substantia.
(p) ‹totius pietatis auctori› · printed under col 442
Sic ex Lectionario Veneto. Al., in multarum; quo etiam confirmatur lectio antea vulgatorum, auctori, pro qua Quesnellus auctor supposuit.
So from the Venice Lectionary. Others, in multarum; by which is also confirmed the reading of the earlier printed editions, auctori, for which Quesnel substituted auctor.
(a) ‹facile est invenire hilarem› · printed under col 443
Al., datorem.
Others, datorem.
(b) ‹commune fit meritum.› · printed under col 443
Cod. Venet., quoniam potest par eorum esse animus.
The Venice ms., quoniam potest par eorum esse animus.
(c) ‹Nihil in tali populo› · printed under col 443
Prima editio cum mss. posteriorum collect,, inornatum.
The first edition with the mss. of the later collections, inornatum.
(d) ‹magnanimitas paucorum est,› · printed under col 443
Conjunctionem et adjecimus ex mss. Veneto et duobus Vatt.; etiam vero ex editionibus ante Quesnellum et quatuor codd. revocavimus. Paulo ante editiones Quesnello anteriores corrupte praeponebant particulam cum voci magnanimitas..
We have added the conjunction et from the Venice ms. and two Vatican ones; and etiam we have restored from the editions before Quesnel and four mss. A little before, the editions earlier than Quesnel corruptly put the particle cum before the word magnanimitas.
(e), (f), (g) printed under col 443 but called in col 444, set in n444
(e) ‹Ubi autem spiritus› · printed under col 443
Cod. Venetus, Domini.
The Venice ms., Domini.
(f) ‹nobis atque illis› · printed under col 443
Jejunium scilicet decimi et septimi mensis ex observantia veteris legis assumptum Leo saepe commemorat; et eatenus Judaeis commune in temporibus hoc loco traditur.
Leo often mentions that the fast of the tenth and of the seventh month was taken over from the observance of the old law; and to that extent it is said in this place to be common with the Jews in the seasons.
(g) ‹Habeant illi› · printed under col 443, continued under col 444
Ritum ex pharisaica procul dubio superstitione descendentem arguit: nihil enim tale praescriptum Judaeis in Scriptura legimus. Haustus porro ex ethnicorum consuetudine, quam commemorat Tertullianus lib. de Jejuniis, in fine: Sed et omnem, inquit, ταπεινοφρόνησιν ethnici agnoscunt. Cum stupet coelum, et aret annus, nudipedalia denuntiantur, etc. Haeresim commemorat Augustinus hominum nudis pedibus semper ambulantium, eo quod Dominus Moyses, Josue et Isaiam nudis pedibus ambulare jusserit. Haeres. 68. QUESNELLUS.
He censures a rite descending without doubt from Pharisaic superstition: for we read of nothing of the kind prescribed to the Jews in Scripture. It was drawn, moreover, from the custom of the heathen, which Tertullian mentions at the end of his book On Fasting: But the heathen too, he says, recognize every humiliation (ταπεινοφρόνησιν). When the sky is dumbstruck and the year is dry, barefoot processions are proclaimed, etc. Augustine mentions a heresy of men who always walked with bare feet, because the Lord ordered Moses, Joshua and Isaiah to walk with bare feet. Heresies 68. QUESNEL.
(h) ‹in tristitia vultuum› · printed under col 444
Sic ex Lectionar. Veneto. Al., ostendant. Respicit hic ad illa Matth. VI, 16, de hypocritis jejunantibus. Exterminant enim facies suas, ut appareant hominibus jejunantes. Amen dico vobis, receperunt mercedem suam; et ideo otiosa ejusmodi jejunia appellat, quod aeterna mercede careant. Confer quae traduntur serm. 92, c. 2.
So from the Venice Lectionary. Others, ostendant. He looks here to those words of Matt. 6:16 about hypocrites who fast: For they disfigure their faces, that they may appear to men as fasting. Amen I say to you, they have received their reward; and so he calls fasts of this kind idle, because they lack an eternal reward. Compare what is said in Sermon 92, ch. 2.
(i) ‹nos in nullo› · printed under col 444
Quesnellus in margine: Forte, ab habitus nostri honestate.
Quesnel in the margin: Perhaps ab habitus nostri honestate.
(j) ‹modus eligatur, non› · printed under col 444
Innuuntur cibi quos Hebraei velut immundos damnabant, ut caro suina, sanguis, etc. Ab his autem abstinebant Christiani etiam Leonis aetate in jejunio quatuor temporum, eo quod carnes non comederent parcitatis ac temperantiae nomine, non vero quod aliquem cibum Hebraica superstitione reprobarent.
The foods are meant which the Hebrews condemned as unclean, such as pork, blood, etc. From these Christians abstained even in Leo's time during the fast of the Four Seasons, because they did not eat meat for the sake of sparingness and temperance, but not because they rejected any food out of Hebrew superstition.
SYNOPSIS. — I. Jejunium a Christianis gratia Dei impletum quantum praestet observantia carnali Judaeorum. — II. Commune et publicum privato esse anteferendum, ut majoris meriti et efficaciae. — III. Innumera esse tela diaboli, quae ab eo solo vitantur qui Deum super omnia diligit. — IV. Quaedam tempora electa, ut ad divina respiremus. — V. Jejunio subjungendam eleemosynam, maxime erga fideles. — VI. Pauperes patientia, divites misericordia salvandos.
SYNOPSIS. — I. How far the fast fulfilled by Christians through the grace of God surpasses the carnal observance of the Jews. — II. That what is common and public is to be preferred to what is private, as being of greater merit and efficacy. — III. That the darts of the devil are countless, and are avoided only by him who loves God above all things. — IV. That certain seasons have been chosen so that we may breathe again towards divine things. — V. That almsgiving is to be joined to fasting, above all towards the faithful. — VI. That the poor are to be saved by patience, the rich by mercy.
(a) ‹est efficacior› · printed under col 445
Al, sanctiorque.
Others, sanctiorque.
(b) ‹ubi vigilat cura communis.› · printed under col 445
Ita cum Quesnello ms. Venetus. Caeterae editiones cum codd. collect. posteriorum: Teneant... observantiae.
So the Venice ms. with Quesnel. The other editions with the mss. of the later collections: Teneant... observantiae.
(c) ‹divinae protectionis auxilio,› · printed under col 445
Vulgati, arripiat. Placuit lectio ms. Veneti.
The printed editions, arripiat. The reading of the Venice ms. pleased [us].
(d) ‹et haec est› · printed under col 445
In prima editione deest una.
In the first edition una is lacking.
(e) ‹Trahunt oculos ad varias› · printed under col 445
Eadem editio, tentationes.
The same edition, tentationes.
(f) ‹accendantur faces, aut› · printed under col 445, continued under col 446
Respicere videtur superstitionem gentium quae astrorum pulchritudine captae ex astris fecerunt deos, vel Manichaeorum, qui soli ac lunae superstitiosum cultum deferre ab ipso Leone inventi fuerunt, uti traditur serm. 42, c. 5, et ep. 15, ad Turibium, c. 4. Vide etiam peculiarem supersitionem erga solem nascentem a paganis derivatam serm. 27. c, 4,
He seems to have in view the superstition of the Gentiles, who, captivated by the beauty of the stars, made gods of the stars, or that of the Manichaeans, who were found by Leo himself to offer superstitious worship to the sun and moon, as is related in Sermon 42, ch. 5, and Letter 15, to Turibius, ch. 4. See also the peculiar superstition towards the rising sun derived from the pagans, Sermon 27, ch. 4.
(g) ‹gignantur errores.› · printed under col 446
Ita ex ms. Veneto. Prima editio: Insidioso enim sono et mollibus actibus. Subsequentes editiones quae a prima non habent originem: Insidioso etiam sono mollibus ictibus. Quesnellus: Insidiosis etiam sonis et mollibus ictibus.
So from the Venice ms. The first edition: Insidioso enim sono et mollibus actibus. The subsequent editions which do not derive from the first: Insidioso etiam sono mollibus ictibus. Quesnel: Insidiosis etiam sonis et mollibus ictibus.
(f) continued from col 445, set in n445
(g) printed under col 446 but called in col 445, set in n445
(h) ‹in amorem› · printed under col 446
Supplevimus vocem ejus ex laudato ms. Veneto.
We have supplied the word ejus from the Venice ms. already cited.
(i) ‹et quia portio› · printed under col 446
Vulgati, divini agri. Melius ex cod. Veneto Dominici, quod Leoni usitatum est.
The printed editions, divini agri. Better, from the Venice ms., Dominici, which is usual with Leo.
(j) ‹sicut scriptum est,› · printed under col 446
Particulam et, quae in Rainaudo et Quesnello deerat, ex omnibus nostris codd. et anterioribus editionibus revocavimus. Cod. Venet., pro pauperum, habet, pauperis.
The particle et, which was lacking in Rainaud and Quesnel, we have restored from all our mss. and the earlier editions. The Venice ms. has pauperis for pauperum.