PL 54 · cols. 281–284
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermon XLIII
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 281–284
Sermon XLIII
(a) ‹anchor: contineamus› · printed under col 281
Post verba, ab omni malitia contineamus, leguntur in aliis editionibus viginti fere lineolae, in quibus haec verba: Secunda igitur et quarta et sexta feria jejunemus, etc., quae scriptoribus ecclesiasticis amplam disputandi materiem praebuere. Ea e sermonis contextu eliminanda censuimus, cum mss. quinque codicum auctoritate, tum aliis pluribus freti argumentis, quae in dissertatione de Sabbati jejunio fuse expenduntur. Quesn. — Nos in solis mss. posteriorum collectionum 3, 4 et 5, eas lineolas reperimus, non vero in mss. collect. 1 et 2, nec in Lectionariis S. Petri, Venet., Patav., Vallicell., Padiliron., etc. Verba autem expuncta haec sunt: Cum inimicis autem crucis Christi nulla consensione jungamur, ne impiorum consortio sanctitas fidelium polluatur. Lux separetur a tenebris, et fugiant filios diaboli filii veritatis. In templum autem Domini, quod est Ecclesia Christi, nihil contaminatum inferri, nihil profanum oportet admitti: ut omni immunditia a penetralibus cordis exclusa, sanctificetur jejunium nostrum, et simus aeternum habitaculum sancti Spiritus, qui nos a peccatorum sordibus emundatos et possidere semper dignetur et regere. Secunda igitur et quarta et sexta feria jejunemus, sabbato autem apud beatum Petrum apostolum vigilias celebremus, qui commendati sibi gregis curam habere non desinens, custodiam nobis de suis precibus obtinebit. Auxiliante nobis per omnia, etc.
After the words "let us refrain from all malice", about twenty short lines are read in other editions, among which are these words: "Let us fast, then, on the second, fourth and sixth day," etc., which have given ecclesiastical writers ample matter for dispute. We judged that they should be removed from the context of the sermon, relying both on the authority of five manuscript codices and on several other arguments, which are weighed at length in the dissertation on the Saturday fast. Quesn. — We have found those lines only in the manuscripts of the later collections 3, 4 and 5, but not in the manuscripts of collections 1 and 2, nor in the Lectionaries of St Peter's, Venice, Padua, the Vallicelliana, Polirone, etc. The words struck out are these: "But let us be joined by no agreement with the enemies of the cross of Christ, lest the holiness of the faithful be polluted by the fellowship of the ungodly. Let light be separated from darkness, and let the sons of truth flee the sons of the devil. Into the temple of the Lord, which is the Church of Christ, nothing defiled may be brought, nothing profane admitted; so that, all uncleanness being shut out from the inner recesses of the heart, our fast may be sanctified, and we may be an eternal dwelling-place of the Holy Spirit, Who may deign always both to possess and to rule us, cleansed from the filth of sins. Let us fast, then, on the second, fourth and sixth day, and on the Sabbath let us celebrate the vigils at the church of blessed Peter the apostle, who, never ceasing to have care of the flock entrusted to him, will obtain protection for us by his prayers. With [God] helping us in all things," etc.
(b) ‹anchor: per omnia Deo› · printed under col 281
Cod. Venet. addit Patre.
The Venice codex adds "the Father".
(c) ‹anchor: De Quadragesima V.› · printed under cols 281–282
Hic sermo insertus invenitur appendici sermonum S. Augustini, cui in aliquibus mss. perperam ascribitur. Est ibidem serm. 148, al. 36 olim de Tempore 73.
This sermon is found inserted in the appendix of the sermons of St Augustine, to whom it is wrongly ascribed in some manuscripts. It is there serm. 148, otherwise 36, formerly De Tempore 73.
(d) ‹anchor: Apostolica, dilectissimi› · printed under col 282
Exemplar Pauli Diac., sententia. Dein prima editio, ut deponamus... et de die in diem... renovemur.
The exemplar of Paul the Deacon [reads] "sententia" (teaching). Then the first edition [reads] "that we put off ... and from day to day ... be renewed".
(e) ‹anchor: antiquitate corruptum› · printed under col 282
Addidimus cita ex Homil. Pauli Diac. et app. Augustini.
We have added "cita" (prompt) from the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon and the appendix of Augustine.
(f) ‹anchor: aedificium nostrum› · printed under col 282
Ita cum Quesnello et prima editione duo codd. S. Petri, alius Vat., exemplar Pauli Diac. et app. Aug. Al., sine opere.
So [read], with Quesnel and the first edition, two codices of St Peter's, another Vatican one, the exemplar of Paul the Deacon and the appendix of Augustine. Others [read] "sine opere" (without the work).
(g) ‹anchor: auctoris nostri› · printed under col 282
Sic melius ex cod. Veneto et prima editione, quam in aliis edit., exstruit. Quesnelli annotationem in verba sequentia, in observationibus ad hunc sermonem dabimus.
So [we read "exstruxit"], better, from the Venice codex and the first edition, than "exstruit" in other editions. Quesnel's annotation on the following words we shall give in the observations on this sermon.
(h) ‹anchor: bona esse, defieiat› · printed under col 282
Editi ante Quesn., at si quid. Exemplar Pauli Diac., aut si quid. Quesnellus cum appendice Aug., ac si quid, et ita etiam duo codd. S. Petri.
The editions before Quesnel [read] "at si quid". The exemplar of Paul the Deacon, "aut si quid". Quesnel, with the appendix of Augustine, "ac si quid", and so too two codices of St Peter's.
Synopsis. — I. Quomodo gratiae cooperetur homo, ut interius renovetur, quod nemini non est necessarium. — II. Paucos esse quos vel adversa non turbent, vel prospera non inflent. — III. Omnibus necessitatem poenitendi incumbere. — IV. Maxime operibus misericordiae deleri peccata.
Synopsis. — I. How man cooperates with grace so as to be renewed inwardly, which is necessary for everyone. — II. That few are those whom adversity does not trouble or prosperity puff up. — III. That the necessity of repenting lies upon all. — IV. That sins are wiped out above all by works of mercy.
(c) continued from col 281, set in n281
(d)–(h) calls in col 281, printed under col 282, set in n281
(i) ‹anchor: Jacta in Deum› · printed under col 282
Al., cogitatum tuum.
Others [read] "cogitatum tuum" (thy thought).
(j) ‹anchor: insolenter superbit› · printed under col 282
Particulam et restituimus ex prima editione et app. Aug.
We have restored the particle "et" from the first edition and the appendix of Augustine.
(k) ‹anchor: veracia sunt ora› · printed under col 282
Cod. Bon. et prima editio, blandientium.
The Bologna codex and the first edition [read] "blandientium" (of those who flatter).
(l) ‹anchor: hinc decipit› · printed under col 282
Adjectivum mendax in editis inventum Quesnellus in marginem rejecit. Nos ex nostris mss., et Homil. Pauli Diac., append. Aug. ac etiam ex ipso contextu revocavimus.
The adjective "mendax" (lying), found in the editions, Quesnel relegated to the margin. We have recalled it from our manuscripts, and the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon, the appendix of Augustine, and also from the context itself.
(m) ‹anchor: incerta discretio› · printed under col 282
Verbum est reposuimus ex prima editione, ex duobus mss. Vatt. nec non ex Homil. Pauli Diac. et app. Aug.
We have put back the word "est" from the first edition, from two Vatican manuscripts, and also from the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon and the appendix of Augustine.
(n) ‹anchor: Nam licet› · printed under col 282
Duo codd. S. Petri, omnia.
Two codices of St Peter's [read] "omnia" (all things).
(o) ‹anchor: cuncta disponi› · printed under col 282
Prima editio omittit quoniam.
The first edition omits "quoniam" (since).
(a) ‹anchor: etiam magnos animos› · printed under col 283
Exemplar Pauli Diac., concitent.
The exemplar of Paul the Deacon [reads] "concitent" (stir up).
(b) ‹anchor: ad remedia divina› · printed under col 283
Editi ante Quesn., recurrimus.
The editions before Quesnel [read] "recurrimus" (we run back).
(c) ‹anchor: baptismo sunt› · printed under col 283
Ita omnes nostri codd. et editiones Leonis ante Quesn., nec non exemplar Pauli Diac. Solum in mss. S Petri, regenerandi venturi, ubi librariorum errore scriptum apparet, regenerandi pro regenerante. Hinc autem forte manavit ut alii amanuenses transcripserint solam vocem, regenerandi, omissa alia voce venturi, quod append. Aug. et Quesnellus suscepere.
So all our codices and the editions of Leo before Quesnel, and also the exemplar of Paul the Deacon. Only in the manuscripts of St Peter's [is there] "regenerandi venturi", where "regenerandi" appears to have been written for "regenerante" by the error of copyists. From this perhaps it came about that other scribes copied the single word "regenerandi", leaving out the other word "venturi", which the appendix of Augustine and Quesnel adopted.
(d) ‹anchor: cordis nostri› · printed under col 283
Vulgati male, piacula. In melioribus codd. et in app. Aug., ut in prima editione, et apud Quesnellum, specula; et optime quidem: nam S. pontifex loquitur de conscientia justorum gravibus peccatis experte, quae tamquam speculum sedulo tergenda est etiam a pulvere culparum leviorum, ne in graviora decidant.
The common editions wrongly [read] "piacula" (sins). In the better codices and in the appendix of Augustine, as in the first edition and in Quesnel, [it is] "specula" (mirrors); and very rightly: for the holy pontiff is speaking of the conscience of the just, free of grave sins, which like a mirror must be diligently wiped clean even of the dust of lighter faults, lest they fall into graver ones.
(e) ‹anchor: qui tota› · printed under cols 283–284
Quesnellus cum exemplo Pauli Diac., App. Aug. et cod. Veneto, nec non mss. collect. 4 et 5, pro fere habet particulam forte, eamque delet ante adverbium negligentius. Prima editio collect. 3 utrobique habet forte. Commodior est caeterarum editionum lectio textui inserta, cui concinunt mss. S. Petri. App. Aug., transegerunt pro transierunt.
Quesnel, with the copy of Paul the Deacon, the appendix of Augustine and the Venice codex, and also the manuscripts of collections 4 and 5, has the particle "forte" (perhaps) instead of "fere" (almost), and deletes it before the adverb "negligentius". The first edition of collection 3 has "forte" in both places. More suitable is the reading of the other editions, inserted in the text, with which the manuscripts of St Peter's agree. The appendix of Augustine [has] "transegerunt" for "transierunt".
(e) continued from col 283, set in n283
(f) ‹anchor: licentia insipientium› · printed under col 284
Sic ex duobus mss. S. Petri et homil. Pauli Diac. emendavimus. Al., voluptatum. Codex Vat. collect. 3, licentia insipientium, aut dulcedo voluptatum.
So we have corrected from two manuscripts of St Peter's and the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon. Others [read] "voluptatum" (of pleasures). A Vatican codex of collection 3 [reads] "licentia insipientium, aut dulcedo voluptatum" (the licence of the foolish, or the sweetness of pleasures).
(g) ‹anchor: digna observantia celebretur› · printed under col 284
Ita restituimus ex omnibus nostris codd. et editis ante Quesnellum, qui praetulit lectionem appendici Aug. communem, cunctorum fidelium corda sanctificentur.
So we have restored from all our codices and the editions before Quesnel, who preferred the reading shared with the appendix of Augustine, "cunctorum fidelium corda sanctificentur" (let the hearts of all the faithful be sanctified).
(h) ‹anchor: suorum obtineat peccatorum› · printed under col 284
Mss. S. Petri, dicente discipulis Domino. Post pauca, pro aequitati suae, quidam codd. habent aequitatis suae regulam.
The manuscripts of St Peter's [read] "the Lord saying to the disciples". A little further on, for "aequitati suae", some codices have "aequitatis suae regulam" (the rule of His equity).
(i) ‹anchor: foventur infirmi, nonne› · printed under col 284
Lectionar. Venet. S. Marci, auxilio Dei munus (forte manus) expletur ministri.
The Venice Lectionary of St Mark's [reads] "by the help of God the gift (perhaps: the hand) of the minister is fulfilled".