PL 54 · cols. 458–465
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermons XCIV–XCV
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 458–465
Sermons XCIV–XCV
(e)–(g) printed under col 458 have their calls in col 457 and are set in n457
(h) ‹ita in iis quae› · printed under col 458
Editi ante Quesn., ad observantiam christianae fidei, cum codd. collect. 3 et 4. Caeteri nostri codices et mss. Corb. ac Vict. Quesnelli textus lectionem praeferunt.
The editions before Quesnel, ad observantiam christianae fidei, with the codices of collections 3 and 4. Our other codices and the Corbie and St Victor mss. give the reading of Quesnel's text.
(i) ‹et a voluntate tua› · printed under col 458
Lectionarium Venetum, vetare.
The Venice Lectionary, vetare.
(j) ‹extollitur, aut› · printed under col 458
Sic Quesnellus cum nostro Lectionario Veneto. Concinunt mss. collectionis 2, in quibus habetur, vindicta. Caeteri editi, adulatione.
So Quesnel with our Venice Lectionary. The mss. of collection 2 agree, in which vindicta is found. The other printed editions, adulatione.
SYNOPSIS. — I. Magis curandam esse jejunium spiritale quam corporale. — II. In quo spiritale jejunium sit positum et quo auxilio implendum. — III. Cur quatuor temporum jejunium fuerit institutum. — IV. Deum diligi, cum proximus diligitur et juvatur.
SYNOPSIS. — I. That the spiritual fast is to be cared for more than the bodily one. — II. In what the spiritual fast consists, and by what help it is to be fulfilled. — III. Why the fast of the four seasons was instituted. — IV. That God is loved when one's neighbour is loved and helped.
(a) ‹misericordiam sui› · printed under col 459
Duo mss. Vat., Creatoris; alius Vat. et prima editio, Auctoris. Mox ms. Venet., quia ego sanctus sum. Mox vulgati, me diligite. Plurium et potiorum nostrorum exemplarium lectionem secuti sumus. Dein, ad jubentem recurrite in nonnullis mss. legitur.
Two Vatican mss., Creatoris; another Vatican [ms.] and the first edition, Auctoris. Soon after, the Venice ms., quia ego sanctus sum. Soon after, the printed editions, me diligite. We have followed the reading of the more numerous and better of our copies. Then, ad jubentem recurrite is read in some mss.
(b) ‹praestetur auxilium› · printed under col 459
Cod. Venetus, non negabat (lege negabit) opem, qui tribuit voluntatem.
The Venice codex, non negabat (read negabit) opem, qui tribuit voluntatem.
(c) ‹inefficaciter› · printed under col 459
Idem ms. Ven., concupiscet.
The same Venice ms., concupiscet.
(d) ‹litterarum; et› · printed under col 459
Prima editio et duo mss. Vat., ab hoc.
The first edition and two Vatican mss., ab hoc.
(e) ‹jubetur. Quid› · printed under col 459
Particulam autem inseruimus ex quinque nostris codicibus.
We have inserted the particle autem from five of our codices.
(f) ‹in hujus vitae› · printed under col 459
Ex nostris Lectionariis addidimus praepositionem in.
We have added the preposition in from our Lectionaries.
(g) ‹fructibus largitatis;› · printed under col 459
Vulg., et gaudia. Prima editio cum mss. collect. 3, et gaudio. Emendavimus ex codd. collect. 2. Quesnellus hanc periodum, Delectetur, usque ad accipies, expunxit auctoritate mss. Corb. et Vict. Deest etiam in nostro cod. Vat. 544 collect. 5 simili Victorino; sed in aliis mss. legitur, ac etiam in cod. Lect. Veneto, et in Vat. 3836. Post nonnulla, quidquid homini contulisset, est in quibusdum codd.
The printed editions, et gaudia. The first edition with the mss. of collection 3, et gaudio. We have corrected from the codices of collection 2. Quesnel struck out this sentence, from Delectetur as far as accipies, on the authority of the Corbie and St Victor mss. It is also lacking in our Vatican codex 544 of collection 5, which resembles the Victorine; but it is read in other mss., and also in the Venice Lectionary codex and in Vatican 3836. After nonnulla, quidquid homini contulisset is in some codices.
(h) ‹Quarta igitur et› · printed under col 459
Cod. Venet., sexta sabbati.
The Venice codex, sexta sabbati.
(i) ‹misericordi Deo› · printed under col 459
Idem codex, jejunii nostri devotione.
The same codex, jejunii nostri devotione.
(j) ‹ad beatitudinem.› (before the sub-caption De eo quod scriptum est) · printed under col 459, running on under col 460
Prima editio et tres mss. Vat., nec non tabula ms. Casanatensis hanc inscriptionem praeferunt: In festo, seu In festivitate omnium sanctorum. In illo tempore videns Jesus turbas, etc. Nihil dubitandum est quin titulus In festo omnium sanctorum, quod Leonis tempore nondum erat inductum, ex posterioribus Lectionariis dimanet, in quibus hic sermo in eadem festivitate legendus proponitur. In vetustiori quidem Lectionario Vat. 1272 haec inscriptio legitur: Incipit sermo S. Leonis papae in Natali apostolorum de octo beatitudinibus. In ms. Casinensi primae collectionis haec tantum inscriptio praefigitur: De octo beatitudinibus; sed per errorem octo scriptum est, cum de septem tantum beatitudinibus Auctor loquatur. Hujus numeri rationem affert Quesnellus in notatione his verbis: « Observat vir eruditus Joannes Cotelerius in Not. tom. I Mon. Graec. pag. 808, Leonem nostrum septem tantum beatitudines enarrare: quia, ut Augustinus in serm. Dom. in monte explicat, septem illi sunt gradus perficientes hominem, octava vero beatitudo hominis est jam perfecti. » Faustus quidem Manichaeus apud Augustinum lib. V contra eumdem Faustum, alio licet ordine, septem tantum beatitudines a Leone memoratas recenset. Augustinus vero serm. 53, al. 14, inter additos a Parisiensibus de sex tantum beatitudinibus fuse disserit. Porro hic sermo in editis non solum post sequentem describitur, verum etiam post alium Sermonem in evangelium Assumpsit Jesus Petrum, etc., quem nos num. 51 ob momenta ibidem allata ante sermones de Passione ponendum credidimus. Ordinem vero primae editionis et codicum collectionum 3, 4 et 5 secuti sumus, in quibus hic sermonibus de Jejunio septimi mensis immediate subjicitur.
The first edition and three Vatican mss., as well as the manuscript table of the Casanatense, give this heading: On the feast, or On the festival, of All Saints. At that time Jesus, seeing the crowds, etc. There can be no doubt that the title On the feast of All Saints, a feast not yet introduced in Leo's time, derives from later Lectionaries, in which this sermon is set down to be read on that festival. In the older Vatican Lectionary 1272, indeed, this heading is read: Here begins the sermon of St Leo the pope on the Birthday of the apostles, on the eight beatitudes. In the Monte Cassino ms. of the first collection only this heading is prefixed: On the eight beatitudes; but eight was written in error, since the Author speaks of only seven beatitudes. Quesnel gives the reason for this number in a note in these words: "The learned John Cotelier observes, in his notes to vol. I of the Monumenta Graeca, p. 808, that our Leo expounds only seven beatitudes: because, as Augustine explains in the Sermon on the Mount, those seven are the steps that perfect a man, while the eighth beatitude belongs to the man already perfect." Faustus the Manichaean, indeed, in Augustine, book V against the same Faustus, though in another order, lists only seven beatitudes, the ones recorded by Leo. Augustine, however, in sermon 53 (otherwise 14), among those added by the Paris editors, discusses at length only six beatitudes. Further, in the printed editions this sermon is placed not only after the following one, but also after another sermon on the gospel Jesus took Peter, etc., which we, for the reasons given there, thought should be placed as no. 51 before the sermons on the Passion. We have followed the order of the first edition and of the codices of collections 3, 4 and 5, in which this sermon is placed immediately after the sermons on the Fast of the seventh month.
SYNOPSIS. — I. Christum per exteriores medelas animos ad interiores praeparasse, quae per lenitatem gratiae fiunt. — II. Humilitatem, quae omnium esse potest, primum esse gradum ad beatitudinem. — III. Ditissimam potentissimamque apostolorum, Petrique in primis fuisse paupertatem. — IV. Quis luctus iter ad beatitudinem? — V. Quaenam terra mitibus promissa? — VI. Sitim justitiae aliud nihil esse quam Dei amorem. — VII. Misericordia hominem Deo similem effici. — VIII. Cordis oculum mundandum
SYNOPSIS. — I. That Christ by outward remedies prepared souls for the inward ones, which come about through the gentleness of grace. — II. That humility, which can belong to all, is the first step to beatitude. — III. That the poverty of the apostles, and of Peter above all, was most rich and most powerful. — IV. What mourning is a road to beatitude? — V. What land is promised to the meek? — VI. That thirst for justice is nothing other than the love of God. — VII. That man is made like God by mercy. — VIII. That the eye of the heart is to be cleansed […]
(a) ‹Praedicante, dilectissimi, Domino› · printed under col 461
Tria Lectionaria omittunt, nostro.
Three Lectionaries omit nostro.
(b) ‹transferret, est post› · printed under col 461
Duo Lectionaria Vat. 1272 et Padiliron., sanitatem.
Two Lectionaries, Vat. 1272 and that of Polirone, sanitatem.
(c) ‹ut impleretur quod fuerat,› · printed under col 461
Tria mss. Lectonaria: Prophetae Jeremiae promissum dicentis: Ecce dies veniunt, dicit Dominus, et disponam domum Israel. Duo ex his praeterea delent voces, et super domum Juda testamentum novum. ac dein habent, in sensu eorum. Postea pro discipulorum tres codd. Vat., apostolorum.
Three manuscript Lectionaries: Prophetae Jeremiae promissum dicentis: Ecce dies veniunt, dicit Dominus, et disponam domum Israel. Two of these moreover delete the words et super domum Juda testamentum novum, and then have in sensu eorum. Afterwards, for discipulorum, three Vatican codices have apostolorum.
(d) ‹regnum coelorum (Matth. V, 3).› · printed under col 461
Exemplar Pauli Diaconi, De quibus Dominus loqueretur. Cod. Padiliron. habet item, Dominus.
The copy of Paul the Deacon, De quibus Dominus loqueretur. The Polirone codex likewise has Dominus.
(e) call in col 462; the note begins under col 461 and runs on under col 462; set whole in n462.
esse, ut Deus videatur. — IX. Quaenam sit vera pax quae hominem Dei filium efficit.
[…] to be, so that God may be seen. — IX. What is the true peace that makes a man a son of God.
(e) ‹ad opera benignitatis› · printed under col 461, running on under col 462
Apud eumdem Paulum Diac., utantur, et dein, numerent, ac postea, impenderent.
In the same Paul the Deacon, utantur, and then numerent, and afterwards impenderent.
(f) ‹numeret quod› · printed under col 462
Ibidem, ad redimendam.
In the same place, ad redimendam.
(g) ‹paupertatis exemplum› · printed under col 462
Sic ex ms. Padiliron., tribus Vat. et uno Bon., nec non ex prima editione et Homil. Pauli Diac. Al., primum.
So from the Polirone ms., three Vatican mss. and one of Bologna, and also from the first edition and the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon. Others, primum.
(h) ‹fidei suae imitatione fecerunt, quando› · printed under col 462
Prima editio, illis primitiis; Paulus Diac., in illis primitivis. Retinuimus lectionem vulgatam, sed inseruimus vocem filiis, quae desiderabatur, auctoritate antiqui Lectionarii Vaticani 1272.
The first edition, illis primitiis; Paul the Deacon, in illis primitivis. We have kept the common reading, but have inserted the word filiis, which was wanting, on the authority of the ancient Vatican Lectionary 1272.
(i) ‹nihil habere de mundo, et omnia› · printed under col 462
Exemplar Pauli Diac., habere.
The copy of Paul the Deacon, habere.
(j) ‹et aurum non est› · printed under col 462
Vulg., mecum. Secuti sumus ms. Padiliron. et idem exemplar Pauli Diac.
The common text, mecum. We have followed the Polirone ms. and the same copy of Paul the Deacon.
(a) ‹addidit Dominus, dicens› · printed under col 463
In eodem Pauli Diac. exemplo sequens beatitudo mitium cum toto capite sequenti hic ponitur: Beati mites, etc. Deinde subjicitur beatitudo lugentium cum toto hoc capite sic: Post haec Dominus ait, et dicit: Beati qui lugent, etc. Postea caput sextum prosequitur hoc initio: Deinde Dominus ait: Beati qui esuriunt, etc. Ita ergo beatitudo mitium in antiquo codice, quo Paulus Diaconus usus est, beatitudini lugentium praeponebatur: uti eodem quidem ordine hae duae beatitudines et recensentur in Evangelio Vulgato, et ab Hilario, Augustino aliisque Patribus explicantur. Nihil tamen immutandum censuimus, non solum quia ordinem in textu editum exhibent omnes collectionum codices quos vidimus, verum etiam quia hic idem ordo servatur in Graeco textu, et ab auctore etiam antiquo Operis Imperf. in Matthaeum homil. 9 adhibetur: unde in aliquot etiam Latinis exemplaribus ab eodem inventus fuit. Enimvero hic ordo exhibetur in duobus vetustissimis Evangeliorum libris, Veronensi et Brixiano, quos P. Joseph Blanchinius novissime edidit in opere inscripto, Evangelium quadruplex, t. I, pag. 25.
In the same copy of Paul the Deacon the following beatitude, of the meek, is placed here with the whole of the following chapter: Beati mites, etc. Then the beatitude of those who mourn is added with the whole of this chapter, thus: Post haec Dominus ait, et dicit: Beati qui lugent, etc. Afterwards the sixth chapter follows with this beginning: Deinde Dominus ait: Beati qui esuriunt, etc. Thus in the ancient codex which Paul the Deacon used the beatitude of the meek was placed before the beatitude of those who mourn: in which order indeed these two beatitudes are both listed in the Vulgate Gospel and explained by Hilary, Augustine and other Fathers. We have judged, however, that nothing should be changed, not only because all the codices of the collections that we have seen show the order printed in the text, but also because this same order is kept in the Greek text, and is used also by the ancient author of the Opus Imperfectum in Matthaeum, homily 9: whence it was also found by him in some Latin copies. And indeed this order is shown in two very ancient books of the Gospels, the Verona and the Brescia books, which Fr Joseph Bianchini has very recently edited in the work entitled Evangelium quadruplex, vol. I, p. 25.
(b) ‹cum mundi hujus› · printed under col 463
Editi, affectione. Quesnellus in margine notavit: Forte, afflictione, quod auctoritate exemplaris Pauli Diac. inseruimus.
The printed editions, affectione. Quesnel noted in the margin: Perhaps afflictione, which we have put in on the authority of the copy of Paul the Deacon.
(c) ‹mens videndo Deo intenta nullis› · printed under col 463
Idem Pauli Diac. exemplar, corporeae molis. Postea cod. Padiliron., contra imperium sui auctoris.
The same copy of Paul the Deacon, corporeae molis. Afterwards the Polirone codex, contra imperium sui auctoris.
(d) ‹induerit incorruptionem,› · printed under col 464
In eodem exemplo, et mortale sumpserit immortalitatem.
In the same copy, et mortale sumpserit immortalitatem.
(d) call in col 463, printed under col 464; set in n463.
(e) ‹si nihil de ejus suavitate gustasset.› · printed under col 464
Audiendo autem dicentem sibi prophetiae spiritum apud eumdem Paulum Diac. Item, audiendo in ms. Padiliron.
Audiendo autem dicentem sibi prophetiae spiritum in the same Paul the Deacon. Likewise audiendo in the Polirone ms.
(f) ‹quamdam supernae dulcedinis› · printed under col 464
Mss. Vat. tres et prima editio, potionem. Mox in eadem editione, supernae, pro castissimae. Post pauca cod. Padiliron., ex toto corde tuo, et ex tota anima tua, et ex tota mente tua, et ex tota voluntate tua: quoniam, etc.
Three Vatican mss. and the first edition, potionem. Soon after, in the same edition, supernae for castissimae. A little further on, the Polirone codex, ex toto corde tuo, et ex tota anima tua, et ex tota mente tua, et ex tota voluntate tua: quoniam, etc.
(g) ‹Denique sicut› · printed under col 464
Ita melius ex nostris mss., cum illi dilectioni respondeat huic desiderio. Editi, illic dilectioni. Prima tamen editio, quae illic dilectioni praefert, cohaerentius dein habet, hic desiderio, sicut etiam in cod. Padiliron.
So, better, from our mss., since illi dilectioni answers to huic desiderio. The printed editions, illic dilectioni. The first edition, however, which shows illic dilectioni, then has more consistently hic desiderio, as also in the Polirone codex.
(h) ‹CAP. VII. —› · printed under col 464
Apud Paulum Diac.: Beati misericordes quoniam ipsi misericordiam consequentur. Agnosce dignitatem Christianae sapientiae; ad quales disciplinarum artes, ad quae praemia voceris intellige. In ms. Padiliron.: Agnosce dignitatem, Christiane, sapientiae.
In Paul the Deacon: Beati misericordes quoniam ipsi misericordiam consequentur. Agnosce dignitatem Christianae sapientiae; ad quales disciplinarum artes, ad quae praemia voceris intellige. In the Polirone ms.: Agnosce dignitatem, Christiane, sapientiae.
(i) ‹ut in creatura› · printed under col 464
Vocabulum sua a Quesnello omissum, uti in nostro Padiliron. deest, restituimus ex caeteris editionibus nostrisque codd. et Homil. Pauli Diac.
The word sua, omitted by Quesnel, as it is lacking in our Polirone ms., we have restored from the other editions and our codices and the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon.
(j) ‹omnia munda sunt, ad eam› · printed under col 464
Particulam quoque, in Quesnelli edit. praetermissam, ex iisdem editis et omnibus mss. revocavimus.
The particle quoque, passed over in Quesnel's edition, we have brought back from the same printed editions and all the mss.
(a) ‹Et tamen hoc consequetur› · printed under col 465
Cod. Padiliron., cum transformabitur caro humana, ut, etc.
The Polirone codex, cum transformabitur caro humana, ut, etc.
(b) ‹cordis promittitur puritati.› · printed under col 465
Prima editio: Splendorem ejus veri luminis. Mox sordida acies in Homil. Pauli Diac. et ms. Padiliron.
The first edition: Splendorem ejus veri luminis. Soon after, sordida acies in the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon and the Polirone ms.
(c) ‹oculi tergantur interiores,› · printed under col 465
Ita ex codd. Casinensi et Padiliron., quibus favet exemplar Pauli Diac., in quo legitur: Ut intuitus tanta visione pascatur. Vulgati, tantum Dei visione.
So from the Monte Cassino and Polirone codices, which the copy of Paul the Deacon supports, in which is read: Ut intuitus tanta visione pascatur. The common editions, tantum Dei visione.
(d) ‹non cujuslibet consensionis,› · printed under col 465
Ita exemplar Pauli Diac., et cod. Padiliron., et duo Lectionaria Vat., quorum unum, pro qualiscumque, habet alicujus. Editi, aut qualiscumque. Post nonnulla diligentibus nomen tuum in iisdem mss. Vat.
So the copy of Paul the Deacon, and the Polirone codex, and two Vatican Lectionaries, of which one has alicujus for qualiscumque. The printed editions, aut qualiscumque. A little after, diligentibus nomen tuum in the same Vatican mss.
(e) ‹ad societatem filiorum› · printed under col 465
Cod. Padilir. delet Dei, et paulo post, mente.
The Polirone codex deletes Dei, and a little after, mente.
(f) call in col 466, printed under col 465; set in n466. (g) call in col 466; the note begins under col 465 and runs on under col 466; set whole in n466.