PL 54 · cols. 244–248
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermon XXXIV
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 244–248
Sermon XXXIV
(e) ‹Omnes gentes,› · printed under col 243
Cod. Casin., quas fecisti. . . . . et honorificabunt nomen. Patav. quoque habet, et honorificabunt, loco et glorificabunt; et dein, in conspectu, pro ante conspectum.
The Monte Cassino codex, "quas fecisti . . . . . et honorificabunt nomen". The Padua [codex] too has "et honorificabunt" in place of "et glorificabunt"; and then "in conspectu" for "ante conspectum".
(f) ‹de longinquitate suae regionis› · printed under col 244
In editis et aliquot codd., excitatos. Quesnellus in margine, forte excitos; quam lectionem cum nacti simus in duobus mss. S. Petri, et duobus Vat., ac uno Patav., textui inserere ⟨n⟩on dubitavimus.
In the editions and some codices, "excitatos". Quesnel in the margin, "perhaps excitos"; and since we have met with this reading in two manuscripts of St Peter's, two Vatican ones and one of Padua, we have not hesitated to insert it in the text.
(g) ‹stella perduxit› · printed under col 244
Post verbum perduxit, haec alia addita leguntur in Codd. excusis: Et recte intuentibus quotidie apparere non desinit. Et si potuit notum facere Christum in infantia latentem, quanto magis potest eumdem manifestare in majestate regnantem! Quae cum in omnibus quos vidi mtlioris notae codd. mss. desiderentur, in duobus scilicet Thuaneis et uno Corbeiensi, dubium non est, ut mihi quidem videtur, quin ex annotatione marginali alicujus astrologiae plus aequo dediti, in textum tandem irrepserint. Sed vel ipsa textus series expungenda esse illa verba manifeste demonstrat. Quesn. — Ista pariter verba absunt a codd. collect. 1 et 2, nec non a quibusdam nostris Lectionariis Patav., Veneto, etc. Quod si in mss. S. Petri leguntur nihil moveat: nam post vocem regnantem habent cum Patre et Spiritu sancto, in saecula saeculorum, Amen; et mox subjicitur: Cujus utique famulatus, etc. Ea autem clausula, cum Patre, etc., ante finem sermonis inserta, eorum verborum intrusionem magis magisque confirmat.
After the word "perduxit" these further words are read, added, in the printed codices: "And to those who look rightly it does not cease to appear daily. And if it could make known Christ lying hidden in infancy, how much more can it manifest the same reigning in majesty!" Since these are missing in all the manuscript codices of better note that I have seen, namely two of de Thou and one of Corbie, there is no doubt, as it seems to me at least, that they finally crept into the text from a marginal annotation of someone given more than was right to astrology. But the very sequence of the text plainly shows that those words are to be struck out. Quesnel. — These words are likewise absent from the codices of collections 1 and 2, and also from some of our Lectionaries, of Padua, Venice, etc. That they are read in the manuscripts of St Peter's should not move anyone: for after the word "regnantem" they have "with the Father and the Holy Spirit, for ages of ages, Amen"; and then there follows: "Cujus utique famulatus", etc. That clause, "with the Father", etc., inserted before the end of the sermon, confirms more and more the intrusion of those words.
(h) ‹huic gratiae,› · printed under col 244
Prima editio, qua omnes invitantur ad Christum.
The first edition, "by which all are invited to Christ".
(i) ‹In Epiphaniae solemnitate IV.› (call before the sub-caption) · printed under col 244
Cod. S. Petri, De Epiphania contra Manichaeos.
The codex of St Peter's, "On the Epiphany, against the Manichaeans".
Synopsis. — I. Magi a longinqua regione vocati, ut Christiana fides roboraretur, quae Deum et hominem Christum credit. — II. Magi prophetia Balaam edocti, Judaeorum responso confirmati. Isti spe ducis temporalis decepti; Herodes timore consortis turbatus. — III. Magorum iter munerumque delectus gratiae intus docentis opus fuere. Eorum diligentia fidei nostrae serviebat. — IV. Manichaeorum impietas incarnationis fidem ac veritatem evertit. — V. Manichaei vitandi; eorum sacrilegia detecta. Pro iisdem aliisque haereticis preces fundere, Ecclesiae institutum.
Synopsis. — I. The magi were called from a distant region so that the Christian faith, which believes Christ to be God and man, might be strengthened. — II. The magi, taught by the prophecy of Balaam, were confirmed by the answer of the Jews. The Jews were deceived by the hope of a temporal leader; Herod was troubled by fear of a partner. — III. The journey of the magi and the choice of their gifts were the work of grace teaching within. Their diligence served our faith. — IV. The impiety of the Manichaeans overturns the faith and the reality of the incarnation. — V. The Manichaeans are to be avoided; their sacrileges are exposed. To pour out prayers for them and other heretics is an institution of the Church.
(a) ‹quae nobis post› · printed under col 245
Quesnellus hoc loco addit, istum, quod et ab aliis editis, et a nostris ms. abest, et sensu ipso postulante expungendum fuit. Melius cum ms. Veron., illum legi posset.
Quesnel adds "istum" at this place, which is absent both from the other editions and from our manuscripts, and had to be struck out as the sense itself requires. It could better be read "illum", with the Verona manuscript.
(b) ‹solemni veneratione› · printed under col 245
Sic restituimus ex nostris codd. et editis ante Quesnellium, apud quem, colitur.
So we have restored from our codices and the editions before Quesnel, in whom [it reads] "colitur".
(c) ‹documenta probaretur› · printed under col 245 (its letter reads as (e) in the scan; italic c and e are hard to tell apart)
Ita duo codd. S. Petri et duo Vat., ac Veron. unus cum Quesnello. Alii editi, veri hominis in Christo orta natura.
So two codices of St Peter's and two Vatican ones, and one Verona one, with Quesnel. The other editions: "veri hominis in Christo orta natura".
(d) ‹contra omnes› · printed under col 245
Editi ante Quesnellum, pronuntiabitur, ut in codd. collect. 3 et 4. Secuti sumus Quesnelli lectionem, quam mss. S. Petri et duo Vat. confirmant. Cod. Veron., muniebatur. Mox, factum est pro gestum est, in uno Vat. collect. 5.
The editions before Quesnel: "pronuntiabitur", as in the codices of collections 3 and 4. We have followed Quesnel's reading, which the manuscripts of St Peter's and two Vatican ones confirm. The Verona codex: "muniebatur". Shortly after, "factum est" for "gestum est" in one Vatican [codex] of collection 5.
(e) ‹quod tanto nuntiabatur› · printed under col 245
In tribus nostris codd. ac prima editione, judicio. Paulo post, dicere pro disseri in duobus mss. S. Petri. Ms. Veron., discere.
In three of our codices and the first edition: "judicio". A little after, "dicere" for "disseri" in two manuscripts of St Peter's. The Verona manuscript: "discere".
(f) ‹existlmantes se› · printed under col 245, running over to col 246
Prima editio et unus Vat., signatum, alius Vat., significatum sibi puerum.
The first edition and one Vatican [codex]: "signatum"; another Vatican one: "significatum sibi puerum".
(f) continued from col 245, set in n245
(g) ‹Bethleem, terra Juda,› · printed under col 246
Ita quatuor Vat. et Veron. unus cum Quesnello, et similiter serm. 32, c. 3. Alii editi, nequaquam minima es. Duo codd. S. Petri, non eris minima.
So four Vatican [codices] and one Verona one, with Quesnel, and similarly Sermon 32, ch. 3. The other editions: "nequaquam minima es". Two codices of St Peter's: "non eris minima".
(h) ‹Non capit Christum› · printed under col 246
Prima editio, regia tua, cum ms. Veron.
The first edition: "regia tua", with the Verona manuscript.
(i) ‹viderant Jesum,› · printed under col 246
Prima editio cum ms. Veneto et codd. Vat. collect. 3, 4 et 5, nec aliquo contuitu ejus, quod eum tam ordinate venerarentur. Similiter cod. Veron., qui solum omittit eum. Editio Rainaudi pro quod habet quo. Cod. Casanat. collect. 2, nec aliquod contuitu, quo tam ordinate venerarentur. Quesnellus, licet nihil indicet, ex his variis lectionibus unam compegisse videtur, quam nullibi invenimus: Nec aliquid contuitu ejus, quo cum tam ordinate venerarentur. Lectionem quorum codd. S. Petri et ms. Casinen. collect. 1 exhibuimus. Paulo post, signari sibi, pro sibi significari legitur in prima editione.
The first edition, with the Venetian manuscript and the Vatican codices of collections 3, 4 and 5: "nec aliquo contuitu ejus, quod eum tam ordinate venerarentur". Similarly the Verona codex, which only omits "eum". Raynaud's edition has "quo" for "quod". The Casanatense codex of collection 2: "nec aliquod contuitu, quo tam ordinate venerarentur". Quesnel, though he indicates nothing, seems to have put together from these various readings one which we find nowhere: "Nec aliquid contuitu ejus, quo cum tam ordinate venerarentur". We have given the reading of the [printed: quorum] codices of St Peter's and of the Monte Cassino manuscript of collection 1. A little after, "signari sibi" for "sibi significari" is read in the first edition.
(a) ‹ut sicut omnibus› · printed under col 247
Prima editio omittit nobis.
The first edition omits "nobis".
(b) ‹proficeret, quod› · printed under col 247
Ita nostri fere omnes ac melioris notae codices cum editis ante Quesnellum, et congruentius: nam vox quod in hoc secundo membro non est relativa, sicut nec in primo, uti esse deberet, si legeretur cum Quesnello et codd. collect. 5, nec non Lectionar. Veron., in infantia ipsius.
So nearly all our codices and those of better repute, with the editions before Quesnel, and more consistently: for the word "quod" in this second member is not a relative, just as it is not in the first, as it would have to be if one read, with Quesnel and the codices of collection 5 and also the Verona Lectionary, "in infantia ipsius".
(c) ‹puerum, quantitate› · printed under col 247
Parvum pro parvulum, et discretum pro dissimilem in duobus codd. S. Petri. Etiam ms. Veron. habet discretum.
"Parvum" for "parvulum", and "discretum" for "dissimilem", in two codices of St Peter's. The Verona manuscript also has "discretum".
(d) ‹probatissimum esse› · printed under col 247
Debebat pro decebat scripsimus ex mss. S. Petri tribusque aliis melioris notae codd. ac prima editione. De articulo quidem maxime necessario agitur, qui probatissimus esse debebat. Item ex iisdem S. Petri codd. ac prima edit., suscipiendarum revocavimus, pro excipiendarum.
We have written "debebat" for "decebat" from the manuscripts of St Peter's and three other codices of better repute and the first edition. For the question is of a most necessary article [of faith], which had to be most fully proved. Likewise from the same codices of St Peter's and the first edition we have restored "suscipiendarum" for "excipiendarum".
(e) ‹oculis hominum› · printed under col 247, running over to col 248
Ita edidimus auctoritate mss. S. Petri, Veneto, Ver⟨o⟩n., nec non codd. collect. 1 et 2. Editi cum ms⟨s⟩. trium posteriorum collectionum, actibusque; qu⟨a⟩m lectionem secutus Quesnellus notavit in margine forte legendum, tactibusque. Sed meliores codices hanc emendationem excludunt.
So we have edited on the authority of the manuscripts of St Peter's, the Venetian and the Verona ones, and also the codices of collections 1 and 2. The editions, with the manuscripts of the three later collections: "actibusque"; following this reading Quesnel noted in the margin that perhaps "tactibusque" should be read. But the better codices exclude this emendation.
(f) ‹naturae carnis› · printed under col 248
Vide inter observationes nostras, quae in similem locum serm. 23 ibidem notabuntur. Post pauca, pro hoc opus, in ms. Corb. Quesn. legitur, hoc corpus; et pro credenda, idem eod. ridenda, pro quo legendum, pudenda, Quesnellus in margine suspicatus est; nulli tamen nostri codd. suffragantur.
See among our observations what will be noted there on a similar passage of Sermon 23. A little after, for "hoc opus", in Quesnel's Corbie manuscript is read "hoc corpus"; and for "credenda", the same codex [has] "ridenda", for which Quesnel suspected in the margin that "pudenda" should be read; yet none of our codices supports it.
(e) continued from col 247, set in n247
(g) ‹veteri Testamento› · printed under col 248
Editi, sacrilegae. Praetulimus mss. S. Petri. Mox tres codd., in furoris mendaciis.
The editions: "sacrilegae". We have preferred the manuscripts of St Peter's. Shortly after, three codices: "in furoris mendaciis".
(h) ‹quos illaqueare› · printed under col 248
Sic ex laudatis mss. S. Petri et duobus aliis Vaticanis. Al., potuerunt.
So from the cited manuscripts of St Peter's and two other Vatican ones. Others: "potuerunt".
(i) ‹confirmanda igitur, dilectissimi,› · printed under col 248
Sic ex iisdem mss. S. Petri. Al., nostra.
So from the same manuscripts of St Peter's. Others: "nostra".