PL 54 · cols. 240–243
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermon XXXIII
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 240–243
Sermon XXXIII
(e) ‹si dona› · printed under col 239, running over to col 240
Ita septem nostri codd. In editis, illius irrita non fecimus. Mox, quae promisit in mss. S. Petri et uno Vat.
So seven of our codices. In the editions, "illius irrita non fecimus". Shortly after, "quae promisit" in the manuscripts of St Peter's and one Vatican [codex].
(f) ‹humilitate destruite,› · printed under col 240
Editi ante Quesnellum, avaritiam largitate delete. Ita etiam nostri codd. collect. 3, 4 et 5. At lectionem a Quesnello textui insertam invenimus in duobus mss. S. Petri, in Lectionario Patavino PP. Eremitanorum, in Veron, nec non in codd. collect. 1 et 2. Dein, benedictionum pro beatitudinum in quatuor nostris codd. et prima editione. In ms. S. Petri mereantur pro mereamur.
The editions before Quesnel, "destroy avarice with generosity". So also our codices of collections 3, 4 and 5. But the reading inserted in the text by Quesnel we have found in two manuscripts of St Peter's, in the Padua Lectionary of the Eremitani Fathers, in the Verona [manuscript], and also in the codices of collections 1 and 2. Then "benedictionum" for "beatitudinum" in four of our codices and the first edition. In the manuscript of St Peter's, "mereantur" for "mereamur".
(g) ‹tamen ut› · printed under col 240
Sic ex ms. Petri. Alias, nostri mihil desit.
So from the manuscript of [St] Peter's. Elsewhere, "nostri nihil desit".
(h) ‹quanto magis› · printed under col 240
Addidimus omnibus ex cunctis nostris codd. et editis ante Quesnellum.
We have added "omnibus" from all our codices and the editions before Quesnel.
Synopsis. — I. Tunc Christus mundum liberaturus venit, cum omnes conclusi erant sub peccato, ut nemo de suis meritis gloriaretur. — II. Cur sub Herode natus, cur stella demonstratus? Gratia intus operabatur, ut signum intelligeretur, ut Christus inquireretur. — III. Quanta Judaeorum caecitas Cristo nascente. Implet gentium vocatio promissionem Abrahae factam. — IV. Cur magi, adorato Christo, per aliam viam revertutur. Cur Christo in Aegyptum transferri voluit. — V. Gratiarum actione celebrando haec festivitas, in qua vocationis gentium primitiae. Quomodo stellam imitabimur.
Synopsis. — I. Christ came to set the world free at the time when all were shut up under sin, so that no one might glory in his own merits. — II. Why He was born under Herod, why He was shown by a star. Grace was working within, that the sign might be understood, that Christ might be sought. — III. How great the blindness of the Jews when Christ was born. The calling of the Gentiles fulfils the promise made to Abraham. — IV. Why the magi, having adored Christ, return by another way. Why Christ willed to be carried into Egypt. — V. This festival, in which are the first-fruits of the calling of the Gentiles, is to be celebrated with thanksgiving. How we shall imitate the star.
(a) ‹ut clarior fieret› · printed under col 241
Al., exercendae. Quesnellus, exerendae, cum aliquot nostris mss. Postea, de suo merito in Lectionariis S. Petri.
Others, "exercendae". Quesnel, "exerendae", with some of our manuscripts. Afterwards, "de suo merito" in the Lectionaries of St Peter's.
(b) ‹Hujus autem,› · printed under col 241
Vox dilectissimi a Quesnello adjecta, nobis inventa est in ms. S. Petri.
The word "dilectissimi", added by Quesnel, has been found by us in the manuscript of St Peter's.
(c) ‹quondam beatissimo› · printed under col 241
Duo codd. S. Petri, Petri Abrahae. Paulo ante jam pro quondam in Lectionario Patavino S. Antonii.
Two codices of St Peter's, "Petri Abrahae". A little before, "jam" for "quondam" in the Padua Lectionary of St Anthony's.
(d) ‹comparata, ut› · printed under col 241
Ita emendavimus ex omnibus nostris codd. et nonnullis editis. Prima editio et Quaesn., ab omni. Paulo post in mss, Patav., ut cui coeli.
So we have emended from all our codices and some editions. The first edition and Quesnel, "ab omni". Shortly after, in the Padua manuscripts, "ut cui coeli".
(e) ‹obsequium.› · printed under col 241
Prima editio cum mss. S. Petri, Commonet. Laudatus cod. Patav., Commovit . . . et in mirandi luminis claritate. Dein, magnitudinem sanctificationis, in eadem editione et in mss. Bon. et tribus Vat.
The first edition with the manuscripts of St Peter's, "Commonet". The Padua codex already cited, "Commovit . . . et in mirandi luminis claritate". Then "magnitudinem sanctificationis" in the same edition and in the Bologna manuscripts and three Vatican ones.
(f) call in col 242; the note begins under col 241 and is set in n242
(f) ‹myrrha› · printed under col 241, running over to col 242
Cave ne quid in his verbis Nestoriano dogmati affine suspiceris, dum tam humanam quam divinam in Christo agnoscit personam Leo noster. Quemadmodum enim tertium in illo suppositum cogitari nemo dixerit, cum personam regiam ab utraque illa discretam appellare videtur, sic nec humanum suppositum a Verbo distinctum in Christo somniasse Leo est existimandus. Unicam ergo Christi personam intelligit, quae simul et dignitate regia, et natura humana, et essentia divina per incarnationem Verbi praedita invenitur. Quesn. — Personae quidem nomen veteres nonnumquam accepisse pro tamquam, aliquot exemplis ostendimus not. 71 in tract. 16, lib. i, S. Zenonis, p. 133. Ita hoc loco, honorantes personam regiam, humanam et divinam, idem est ac auro honorantes Christum tamquam regem, myrrha tamquam hominem, thure tamquam Deum; et in hanc quidem sententiam sermone sequenti, c. 3: Cui, inquit, in auro regius honor, in thure divina veneratio, in myrrha mortalitatis confessio deberetur. Confer etiam serm. 36, c. 1. Porro in duplici natura Christi personae unitatem pluribus in locis palam profitetur.
Beware of suspecting in these words anything akin to the Nestorian dogma, when our Leo acknowledges in Christ a human as well as a divine person. For as no one would say that a third subject is to be thought of in Him, when he seems to call the royal person distinct from both of those, so neither is Leo to be thought to have dreamed of a human subject distinct from the Word in Christ. He understands, therefore, the single person of Christ, which is found endowed at once with royal dignity, human nature and divine essence through the incarnation of the Word. Quesnel. — That the ancients sometimes took the noun "persona" in the sense of "as", we have shown with several examples in note 71 on tractate 16, book 1, of St Zeno, p. 133. So in this place "honouring the royal, the human and the divine person" is the same as "honouring Christ with gold as king, with myrrh as man, with incense as God"; and indeed to this effect in the following sermon, ch. 3, he says: "to Whom was due royal honour in the gold, divine veneration in the incense, the confession of mortality in the myrrh". Compare also Serm. 36, ch. 1. Moreover, he openly professes in many places the unity of the person in the twofold nature of Christ.
(g) ‹postulant› · printed under col 242
Nonnulli codd. posteriorum collectionum addunt, puerum. Prima editio, puerum quem ad regendum sibi didicerunt procreatum. Aliquanto post, Ubi est, Judaee, glorificatio tua? in mss. S. Petri, Bon. et prima editione.
Some codices of the later collections add "puerum". The first edition, "the child whom they had learned was begotten to rule for them". Somewhat later, "Where, Jew, is your glorification?" in the manuscripts of St Peter's, Bologna and the first edition.
(h) ‹Quoniam› · printed under col 242
Duo codd. S. Petri, unus Vallicell. et alius Patavinus: Hanc elegit generis dignitatem, ut sicut infidelitas in suis posteris fecit (Patav., convicit, Vallic., convicit) esse degenerem, ita fides omnibus fecit (melius Putav. et Vallicell., faciat) esse communem.
Two codices of St Peter's, one of the Vallicelliana and another of Padua: "He chose this dignity of the race, so that as unbelief made it (Padua, 'convicit'; Vallicelliana, 'convicit') degenerate in its posterity, so faith made it (better, Padua and Vallicelliana, 'faciat') common to all."
(i) ‹non per› · printed under col 242
Prima edito, antiquas. Aliquanto post, furiam post furorem in eadem editione et mss. S. Petri ac Bon.
The first edition, "antiquas". Somewhat later, "furiam" after "furorem" in the same edition and the manuscripts of St Peter's and Bologna.
(a) ‹crudelitatis effundit,› · printed under col 243
Quesnellus hac lectione, quae erat anteriorum editionum, in notationem rejecta, ex tribus codd. id est duobus Thuan. et uno Corb., quibus concinunt nostri Patav., Venet. et Casin., hanc aliam inseruit: Et caede generali in beatam civitatis illius desaevit infantiam. Nos vero antea editorum lectionem restituendam putavimus, eo quod non solum reperiatur in mss. collectionum 3, 4 et 5, verum etiam in Lectionariis libris S. Petri, qui laudatis codicibus praeferendi visi sunt: cum praesertim ad eamdem lectionem accedant mss. Casan. et Barb. collect. 2, in quibus legitur: Et caede generali in universam civitatis illius in aeternam gloriam transituram desaevit infantiam. Concinit etiam Lectionarium Vallicel., in quo solum pro trucidat, est trucidavit. Post pauca: At ille, quia sanguinem, in ms. Patav.
Quesnel, having relegated to a note this reading, which was that of the earlier editions, inserted from three codices, that is, two of de Thou and one of Corbie, with which our Padua, Venice and Monte Cassino [manuscripts] agree, this other one: "And with a general slaughter he raged against the blessed infancy of that city." We, however, thought that the reading of the earlier editors should be restored, because it is found not only in the manuscripts of collections 3, 4 and 5, but also in the Lectionary books of St Peter's, which seemed preferable to the codices cited: especially since the Casanatense and Barberini manuscripts of collection 2 come close to the same reading, in which one reads: "And with a general slaughter he raged against the whole infancy of that city, which was to pass into eternal glory." The Vallicelliana Lectionary also agrees, in which only, for "trucidat", there is "trucidavit". A little after: "At ille, quia sanguinem", in the Padua manuscript.
(b) ‹ut illam› · printed under col 243
Unus cod. S. Petri et alius Vat., duriorem.
One codex of St Peter's and another Vatican one, "duriorem".
(c) ‹qui eripuit nos› · printed under col 243
Cod. S. Petri, de tenebris et de potestate tenebrarum.
The codex of St Peter's, "from darkness and from the power of darkness".
(d) ‹Gentes quae te› · printed under col 243
Ms. Casin., non cognoverunt. Mox, qui te nescierunt, ex eodem cod. scripsimus, cum idem legatur serm. 29, cap. 3. Al., nesciebant. Ms. Patav., nesciunt.
The Monte Cassino manuscript, "non cognoverunt". Shortly after, we have written "qui te nescierunt" from the same codex, since the same is read in Serm. 29, ch. 3. Others, "nesciebant". The Padua manuscript, "nesciunt".
(e) call in col 244; the note is printed under col 243 and set in n244