PL 54 · cols. 168–171
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermon XII
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 168–171
Sermon XII
(c) ‹nostris, ut› · printed under col 167, continued under col 168
Intelliguntur ecclesiae diaconales, ut in admonitione sermoni 6 praemissa observavimus. Hinc male Quesnellus in postilla huic loco apposuit, ecclesiae parochiales, quibus titulares presbyteri, non autem diaconi praeerant.
The deaconry churches are meant, as we observed in the admonition prefixed to sermon 6. Hence Quesnel wrongly set against this place in a marginal note "parish churches", over which titular priests, not deacons, presided.
(d) ‹sit judex.› · printed under col 168
In editione laudata, remaneat diffidentia.
In the edition cited, "remaneat diffidentia" [let distrust remain].
(e) ‹De jejunio decimi mensis I.› · printed under col 168
In prima editione et in codd. collect. 3 hic sermo inscribitur, de Collectis sermo ejusdem VI, et de Jejunio decimi mensis I. Titulus pariter de Collectis additur sermoni sequenti, et hinc in caeteras editiones manavit. Sed perperam: nulla enim in hoc vel sequenti sermone collectarum fit mentio, uti fit in sex praecedentibus, qui vere ad collectas pertinent. Hic sane titulo de Collectis carent mss. caeterarum omnium collectionum, quae cum codd. lectionariis omnes hos sermones inscribunt: de Jejunio mensis decimi.
In the first edition and in the codices of collection 3 this sermon is titled "On the Collections, sermon VI of the same, and On the Fast of the Tenth Month, I". The title "On the Collections" is likewise added to the following sermon, and from there it passed into the other editions. But wrongly: for in this or the following sermon no mention is made of the collections, as there is in the six preceding, which truly concern the collections. Indeed the manuscripts of all the other collections lack this title "On the Collections"; together with the lectionary codices they all title these sermons "On the Fast of the Tenth Month".
(f) ‹creationis nostrae› · printed under col 168
Ms. Casin. collect. 1, intelligimus.
The Monte Cassino manuscript of collection 1 [reads] "intelligimus" [we understand].
(g) ‹gratia Salvatoris,› · printed under col 168
Duo mss. Lectionaria Basilicae S. Petri, et Vat. 541, collect. 4, ut quod cecidit in Adam primo, erigatur in secundo. In antiquissimo Lection. Vat. 3836, et pro dum.
Two manuscript lectionaries of the Basilica of St Peter, and Vatican 541 of collection 4, [read] "ut quod cecidit in Adam primo, erigatur in secundo" [so that what fell in the first Adam may be raised up in the second]. In the very ancient Vatican lectionary 3836, "et" for "dum".
SYNOPSIS. — I. Homo ideo conditus, ut suum imitetur auctorem; et hoc Dei donum est. — II. Charitatem non Deum solum, sed et proximum complecti, ipsosque inimicos; quae Christianae charitatis latitudo est. — III. Omnibus Dei judiciis subditus quisque debet esse, nec minus de inopia quam de abundantia gratias agere. — IV. Jejunio, oratione et eleemosyna omnes virtutes comprehendi.
SYNOPSIS. — I. Man was made in order to imitate his Maker; and this is the gift of God. — II. Charity embraces not God alone but also one's neighbour, and even enemies; this is the breadth of Christian charity. — III. Everyone ought to be subject to all the judgements of God, and to give thanks no less for want than for abundance. — IV. All virtues are comprised in fasting, prayer and almsgiving.
(a) ‹quem non diligeremus,› · printed under col 169
Plerique vulgati ante Quesnellum, nisi prius nos ipse.
Most printed editions before Quesnel [read] "nisi prius nos ipse" [unless He first (loved) us].
(b) ‹Isaiam Dominus› · printed under col 169
Ita duo codd. S. Petri et vetustissimus Vat. necnon Pauli Diaconi Homiliarium editionis Basileensis an. 1496. In editis ante Quesnellum erat denuntians; apud Quesn. vero cum mss. collect. 4 et 5, pronuntians, At ille correctionem optime conjiciens, notavit in margine, forte praenuntians.
So two codices of St Peter's and the very old Vatican, and also the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon in the Basel edition of the year 1496. In the editions before Quesnel it was "denuntians"; in Quesnel, with the manuscripts of collections 4 and 5, "pronuntians". But he, conjecturing the correction very well, noted in the margin "perhaps praenuntians".
(c) ‹Adducam caecos› · printed under col 169
Prima editio cum mss. collect. 3, per viam.
The first edition with the manuscripts of collection 3 [reads] "per viam" [by the way].
(d) ‹illis, et› · printed under col 169
Vat. 3836, non derelinquam.
Vatican 3836 [reads] "non derelinquam" [I will not abandon].
(e) ‹Joannes apostolus› · printed under col 169
Sic nostri codices et editi ante Quesnellum, qui pro docet posuit commemorat, uti est etiam in Homiliario Pauli Diaconi.
So our codices and the editions before Quesnel, who put "commemorat" [records] for "docet", as it is also in the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon.
(f) ‹Scimus, quoniam› · printed under col 169
Apud Paulum Diaconum, jam Filius Dei.
In Paul the Deacon, "jam Filius Dei" [the Son of God has now (come)].
(g) ‹suae charitatis› · printed under col 169
Antiquissimus Vaticanus, et unus S. Petri, inflammat.
The very ancient Vatican, and one of St Peter's, [read] "inflammat" [He sets aflame].
(h) ‹bona est› · printed under col 169
Prima editio et ms. Bonon., illa causa tolerandi, qua se adversis vel corrigi intelligat, vel probari.
The first edition and the Bologna manuscript [read] "illa causa tolerandi, qua se adversis vel corrigi intelligat, vel probari" [that reason for enduring, by which he understands that he is corrected or proved by adversities].
(i) ‹cum quibus nobis› · printed under col 169
Duo codd. S. Petri, mensura atque natura.
Two codices of St Peter's [read] "mensura atque natura" [measure and nature].
(j) ‹iisdem› · printed under col 169
Ita ex prima editione et duobus mss. Vat. et S. Petri. Alias, utimur.
So from the first edition and two manuscripts, the Vatican and St Peter's. Elsewhere, "utimur" [we use].
(k) ‹suas. Et quidem› · printed under col 169
Equidem in Homiliar. Pauli Diac.
"Equidem" in the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon.
(l) ‹implens cibo› · printed under col 169, continued under col 170
Hanc lectionem textui Graeco et Vulgato congruentem praetulimus ex antiquissimo Vaticano Lectionario, ex pervetusto Pauli Diaconi exemplo, nec non ex mss. collect. 4. Alias, justitia. Et mox tres nostri codd., corda vestra.
We have preferred this reading, agreeing with the Greek and Vulgate text, from the very ancient Vatican Lectionary, from a very old copy of Paul the Deacon, and also from the manuscripts of collection 4. Elsewhere, "justitia". And next, three of our codices [read] "corda vestra" [your hearts].
(m) ‹extendens,› · printed under col 170
Aequiorem credimus hanc lectionem primae editionis et mss. collect. 3. In caeteris editis, neminem despectat, dum docet. Codd. Vict., Corb., Thuan et Gaudiival. apud Quesnellum et noster Vat. 531, collect. 4, neminem desperat, dum docet. Alter Vat. 546 collect. 4, unus Vat. 544 collect. 5, duo S. Petri et Homiliar. Pauli Diac., neminem hominem desperat, dum docet. Tandem Vat. 3836, neminem hominum desperat, dum docet.
We believe this reading of the first edition and of the manuscripts of collection 3 to be fairer. In the other editions, "neminem despectat, dum docet". The St Victor, Corbie, de Thou and Gaudiival. codices in Quesnel, and our Vatican 531 of collection 4, [read] "neminem desperat, dum docet" [despairs of no one, while it teaches]. Another, Vatican 546 of collection 4, one Vatican 544 of collection 5, two of St Peter's and the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon, "neminem hominem desperat, dum docet". Finally Vatican 3836, "neminem hominum desperat, dum docet".
(n) ‹gentibus,› · printed under col 170
Legebatur fractis pro sacris non solum in editis, verum etiam in plerisque codicibus; et videbatur convenire cum testimonio Pauli ad Rom. XI, 17 et 19, ubi rami fracti memorantur. Sed praetulimus tria Romanae Ecclesiae Lectionaria Vat. 3836, et duo basilicae S. Petri; cum praesertim non in ramis fractis et abscisis, sed in ramis ex quibus isti abscisi fuerunt insitio fiat; hi autem rami olivae sancti appellantur ab Apostolo v. 16, non minus quam radix. Paulo post in Pauli testimonio prima editio et duo mss. S. Petri omittunt vocem Christus.
"Fractis" [broken] was read for "sacris" not only in the editions but also in most codices; and it seemed to agree with the testimony of Paul to the Romans 11:17 and 19, where broken branches are mentioned. But we have preferred three lectionaries of the Roman Church, Vatican 3836 and the two of the basilica of St Peter; especially since the grafting is made not onto the broken and cut-off branches, but onto the branches from which those were cut off; and these branches of the olive are called holy by the Apostle in verse 16, no less than the root. A little later, in Paul's testimony, the first edition and two manuscripts of St Peter's omit the word "Christus".
(o) ‹Audet› · printed under col 170
Supplevimus enim ex omnibus nostris codicibus et ex Homil. Pauli Diaconi.
We have supplied "enim" from all our codices and from the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon.
(a) ‹defluxerint,› · printed under col 171
Duo mss. Vat. et prima editio, accusatur annus.
Two Vatican manuscripts and the first edition [read] "accusatur annus" [the year is accused].
(b) ‹fideles et› · printed under col 171
Vetustissimus Vat., pacis discipulos. In duobus autem mss. S. Petri: Cumque fidelis et pacis discipulus et veritatis, nihil magis commendet et moneat quam ut perseverans sit in Deum et indefessa laudatio, dicens: Semper gaudete, etc.
The very old Vatican [reads] "pacis discipulos" [disciples of peace]. But in two manuscripts of St Peter's: "And since the faithful disciple both of peace and of truth, nothing commends and admonishes more than that there be persevering and unwearied praise towards God, saying: Rejoice always", etc.
(c) ‹in omnibus› · printed under col 171
Ita ex nostris mss. ac prima editione nec non ex Homiliario Pauli Diaconi. Similiter etiam apud S. Paulum. Aliae editiones et Quesnellus, nobis.
So from our manuscripts and the first edition, and also from the Homiliary of Paul the Deacon. Likewise also in St Paul. Other editions and Quesnel [read] "nobis" [us].
(d) ‹placeat› · printed under col 171
Sic nostri codices. Editi, et omnibus nobis.
So our codices. The printed editions [read] "et omnibus nobis" [and to all of us].
(e) ‹lucris› · printed under col 171
Vatic. 3836, angusto gravabimur fructu.
Vatican 3836 [reads] "angusto gravabimur fructu" [we shall be burdened by a narrow yield].
(f) ‹quod terra› · printed under col 171
Sic tria Lectionaria Romana laudata not. 17. Alias, non dedit.
So the three Roman lectionaries cited in note 17. Elsewhere, "non dedit" [has not given].
(g) ‹viduae› · printed under col 171
Homiliar. Pauli Diac., copiis pietatis suae vacuata. Unus Vat. omittit suae. In prima editione desunt, in opus pietatis suae.
The Homiliary of Paul the Deacon [reads] "copiis pietatis suae vacuata" [emptied by the abundance of her piety]. One Vatican omits "suae". In the first edition the words "in opus pietatis suae" are lacking.
(h) ‹qui in pau-› · printed under col 171
Vocem pauperibus addidimus ex tribus memoatis Lectionariis,
We have added the word "pauperibus" from the three lectionaries mentioned.
(i) ‹omne quidem tempus› · printed under col 172
Homiliar. Pauli Diac., promptum.
The Homiliary of Paul the Deacon [reads] "promptum" [ready].