PL 54 · cols. 157–162
Leo the Great, Sermons
Sermons VI–IX
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 157–162
Sermons VI–IX
(none) Notes (a) and (b) printed under this column are called in col 158 and are set in n158.
The ADMONITIO IN SEQUENTES SERMONES DE COLLECTIS, begun in n156, runs on here in full-width lines across cols 157 and 158 from the head of the page down to the caption of Sermo VI; its continuation is set here once. collectae ejusmodi incurrisse videntur. Initio auiem Julii supertitiosus fuerat dies pridie nonas, quo pagani praecipua solemnitate Apollinares ludos peragebant, in quos etiam celebrandos conferebant nummos. Post Cannensem nimirum cladem instituti fuerunt ex Martii clari vatis carmine, cujus in libris haec inventa Livius recitat lib. XXV, c. 12. Hostes, Romani, si expellere vultis..... Apollini vovendos censeo ludos, qui quotannis comiter Apollini fiant, cum populus dederit ex publico partem, privati ut conferant pro se suisque; iis ludis faciendis praeerit praetor. Hoc carmine invento et ad senatum delato censuerunt Patres Apollini ludos vovendos, faciendosque a praetore Urbis. Hic autem in circo maximo cum facturus esset, edixit ut populus per eos ludos stipem Apollini, quantum commodum essset, conferret. Initio nulla statuta die hi ludi edebantur. At A. U. C. 546, Pr Varus praetor urbanus lege ad populum lata jussus est certum diem statuere. Itaque ipse primus, inquit Livius l. XXVII, ita vovit, fecitque ante diem III nonas Quintiles. Is deinde solemnis servatus. Ex duobus autem antiquis calendariis Maffeiano et Blanchiniano corrigenuus Livii textus. et pro III nonas legendum est II nonas Quintiles: quod pariter confirmat tertium calendarium marmori insculptum et Amiterni repertum, a Muratorio editem tom. I Thesaurii Inscript. pag. 101. Solum calendarium, non tamen ex marmore, sed ex manuscripto Caesareo vulgatum a Lambecio, quod aetate etiam posterius, tribus laudatis praeferendum non est, III nonas ponit. Id autem librariorum lapsu facile contingere potuit. Bollandistae tom. VI Junii parte II, huic calendario, quod Lambecius primus ediderat, e regione apposuerunt aliud antea ineditum calendarium a Polemio Silvio Leonis nostri aetate conscriptum in quo oeque ac in calendariis marmoreis II non memorati ludi assignantur. Una dies initio his ludis constituta, dein eosdem repetitos, sive continuatos in plures dies, ex aliquot veterum testimoniis qui alios et alios dies memorant, collegit Norisius in Cenotaphiis Pisanis dissert. 2, cap. 6, et ante ipsum Manutius de Legibus Romanorum, et Comment. in ep. 1, lib. XVI, ad Atticum. Ex calendario autem Romano, quod primo Ecclsstae saeculo insculptum in museo Capitolino servatur, et a Francisco Blanchinio sditum fuit tom. II Anastasii pag. 305 tab. c, nec non ex Maffeiano sapius recuso, discimus Apollinares ludos inchoasse II non. Julias, et continuasse usque ad IV idus, seu usque ad diem ejusdem mensis duodecimam. in calendario lambeciano iidem ludi Appollinares notantur etiam III idus ejusdem mensis, id est die 13. Id explicatur ex Cicerone ep. 4, l. XVI, ad Atticum, ubi venationem memorat postridie ludos Apollinares, quae velut appendix ludorum Apollinarium habebatur. Hinc calendarium Blanchinianum III id habet In Circo et Maffeianum cum Amiternino eodem die, Ludi in Circo.
[…] collections of this kind seem to have fallen at the beginning of July. At the beginning of July the day before the Nones had been a superstitious day, on which the pagans held the Apollinarian games with special solemnity, and for the celebration of these they also contributed money. They were instituted, namely, after the disaster of Cannae, from the song of the famous seer Marcius, whose words found in his books Livy recites, bk. XXV, c. 12: "Romans, if you wish to drive out the enemy ..... I judge that games must be vowed to Apollo, to be held each year with good cheer for Apollo; when the people have given a part from the public purse, let private persons contribute for themselves and their families; the praetor shall preside over the holding of those games." This song having been found and brought before the senate, the Fathers decreed that games should be vowed to Apollo and held by the praetor of the City. And when he was about to hold them in the Circus Maximus, he proclaimed that during those games the people should contribute an offering to Apollo, as much as was convenient. At first these games were held on no fixed day. But in the year of the City 546, P. Varus, the urban praetor, was ordered by a law carried before the people to fix a set day. "Accordingly he himself first," says Livy, bk. XXVII, "so vowed them, and held them on the third day before the Nones of Quintilis. Thereafter it was kept as a solemn day." From two ancient calendars, however, the Maffei and the Bianchini, Livy's text must be corrected, and for III nonas one must read II nonas Quintiles: which a third calendar, carved in marble and found at Amiternum, published by Muratori in vol. I of the Thesaurus of Inscriptions, p. 101, likewise confirms. Only the calendar published by Lambeck, not from marble but from an imperial manuscript, which is also later in date and is not to be preferred to the three cited, puts III nonas. And this could easily have come about through a slip of the copyists. The Bollandists, in vol. VI of June, part II, set opposite this calendar, which Lambeck had been the first to publish, another calendar not previously published, composed by Polemius Silvius in the age of our Leo, in which, just as in the marble calendars, the said games are assigned to II non. That one day was fixed for these games at first, and that they were afterwards repeated or continued over several days, Noris gathered, in the Cenotaphia Pisana, dissert. 2, cap. 6, from several testimonies of the ancients which mention different days; and before him Manutius, On the Laws of the Romans, and in the Commentary on ep. 1, bk. XVI, to Atticus. From the Roman calendar, moreover, which, carved in the first century of the Church, is kept in the Capitoline Museum and was published by Francesco Bianchini in vol. II of Anastasius, p. 305, table c, and also from the Maffei calendar, often reprinted, we learn that the Apollinarian games began on II non. Jul. and continued until IV idus, that is, until the twelfth day of the same month. In the Lambeck calendar the same Apollinarian games are noted also on III idus of the same month, that is, the 13th. This is explained from Cicero, ep. 4, bk. XVI, to Atticus, where he mentions a hunt on the day after the Apollinarian games, which was regarded as a kind of appendix to the Apollinarian games. Hence the Bianchini calendar has at III id. "In the Circus", and the Maffei calendar, with the Amiternum one, on the same day, "Games in the Circus".
Hac ergo superstitione ab antiquis Patribus in pium usum conversa, primus collectarum dies fuisse videtur II nonas Julii, qui est dies octavae SS. Petri et Pauli; isque ante aliquanto erat indicendus, ut populus ad collectionem sese opportune pararet; ac proinde hos sermones inter diem natalem et octavam SS. apostolorum habitos fuisse verisimillimum est. Quod si tres ex his sermonibus in divinorum officiorum usum assumpti, diebus Dominecis 2, 3 et 4 post natale apostolorum assignati inveniuntur in laudato Lectionario Vallicellano, id posteriori tempore accidit, at Dominicus dies singulis assignaretur; quemadmodum etiam sermo 84, qui ad octavam Aposolorum pertinet, in eodem Lectionario Dominica 6 post eorumdem natale legendus describitur.
This superstition, then, having been turned to a pious use by the ancient Fathers, the first day of the collections seems to have been II nonas Julii, which is the day of the octave of SS. Peter and Paul; and it had to be announced somewhat beforehand, so that the people might prepare themselves for the collection in good time; and accordingly it is most likely that these sermons were delivered between the birthday and the octave of the holy apostles. And if three of these sermons, taken up for use in the divine offices, are found assigned to the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Sundays after the feast of the apostles in the Vallicelliana Lectionary cited, that happened at a later time, so that a Sunday might be assigned to each; just as sermon 84 too, which belongs to the octave of the apostles, is copied in the same Lectionary to be read on the 6th Sunday after their feast.
Ex his porro, quae hactenus constituimus, facile est annum singulorum indicare. Cum enim S. pontifex Romanae Ecclesiae praefuerit ab an. 440 usque ad an. 461, primus et quintus sermo annis distinctis recitati, in quibus indicitur prima collecta die Dominico, assignandi sunt an. 441, vel 447, vel 452, vel 458; his enim annis dies sexta Julii ex tittera Dominicali E incidit in Dominicam. Secundus sermo, qui denuntiat primam collectam feria secunda, ascribendus est an. 442, vel 453, vel 459, in quibus dies II nonas Julias fuit feria secunda: similique ratione tertius sermo, qui designat tertiam feriam adjudicandus est an. 443, vel 448, vel 454, in quibus idem dies fuit feria tertia, ac sermo sextus, qui praefert diem sabbati, habitus fuit an. 446, vel 457, cum dies sextus Jnlii in sabbatum incidit.
From what we have so far established, moreover, it is easy to indicate the year of each. For since the holy pontiff presided over the Roman Church from the year 440 to the year 461, the first and fifth sermons, delivered in different years, in which the first collection is announced for a Sunday, are to be assigned to the year 441, or 447, or 452, or 458; for in these years the sixth day of July, by the Dominical letter E, fell on a Sunday. The second sermon, which announces the first collection for the second feria, is to be ascribed to the year 442, or 453, or 459, in which the day II nonas Julias was the second feria; and by similar reasoning the third sermon, which designates the third feria, is to be assigned to the year 443, or 448, or 454, in which the same day was the third feria; and the sixth sermon, which shows the Sabbath day, was delivered in the year 446 or 457, when the sixth day of July fell on the Sabbath.
Unus dies feriae quartae, qui sermone quarto designatur, cum alio charactere ejusdem sermonis non videtur congruere. Nam hic sermo manifeste habitus fuit cum sub initium detecti erroris Romae ageretur adversus Manichaeos, unde ad hos deferendos apud presbyteros S. pontifex auditores excitat cap. 4. Id autem mense Julio convenit soli anno 444, nam anno 443 Manichaei eo mense nondum detecti fuerant; serius vero hunc sermonem producere usque ad annum 449, vel 455, vel 460, in quibus dies sextus Julii concurrit cum feria quarta hoc sermone designata, Manichaeismi Romae detecti initia nequaquam sinunt. Haec difficultas de indicata a Leone alia superstitiosa solemnitate, cujus prima dies, eidemque alligata prima collectio anno 444, inciderit in feriam quartam, suspicionem injecerat. At cum nulla alia paganorum solemnitas, quae perinde congrueret, inventa nobis fuerit, nulli autem ethnicae superstitioni magis conveniant caeteri omnes horum sermonum characteres, quam ludis Apollinaribus, qui die sexta Julii inchoabantur; mendum in feriae quartae notationem sermone quarto irrepsisse arbitramur. Perfacile autem fuit amanuensium allucinatione feriam quartam legere, aut scribere pro feria quinta; quae sane an, 444 concurrit cum die secundo nonas Julii.
Only the day of the fourth feria, which is designated in the fourth sermon, does not seem to agree with another feature of the same sermon. For this sermon was plainly delivered when, at the beginning of the discovery of the error, proceedings were being taken at Rome against the Manichees; whence in chap. 4 the holy pontiff urges his hearers to report them to the presbyters. And in the month of July this fits the year 444 alone, for in the year 443 the Manichees had not yet been discovered in that month; while the beginnings of the discovery of Manichaeism at Rome by no means allow this sermon to be put later, to the year 449, or 455, or 460, in which the sixth day of July coincides with the fourth feria designated in this sermon. This difficulty had raised the suspicion that Leo had indicated some other superstitious solemnity, whose first day, and the first collection tied to it, fell in the year 444 on the fourth feria. But since no other solemnity of the pagans that would fit equally well has been found by us, and all the other features of these sermons suit no heathen superstition better than the Apollinarian games, which began on the sixth day of July, we judge that an error has crept into the notation of the fourth feria in the fourth sermon. And it was very easy, through a slip of the copyists, to read or write feria quarta for feria quinta; which indeed in the year 444 coincides with the second day before the Nones of July.
SYNOPSIS. — Eleemosynae commendatione praemissa, Dominicam collectarum adesse monet.
SYNOPSIS. — Having first commended almsgiving, he gives notice that the Sunday of the collections is at hand.
(a) ‹O mira providentia› · printed under col 157
Voces et bonitas desunt in prima editione.
The words et bonitas are missing in the first edition.
(b) ‹vertiri ac suscipi› · printed under cols 157–158
Ms. Vallic., testetur. Mox in eodem codice omittuntur voces, cum Patre et Spiritu sancto.
The Vallicelliana manuscript, testetur. Shortly after, in the same codex, the words cum Patre et Spiritu sancto are omitted.
(none) The admonition printed across the full width of the upper part of this page is set in n156 and n157.
(a) ‹in usus atque› · printed under col 159
Prima editio, eleemosynam.
The first edition, eleemosynam.
(b) ‹feriam spontaneas› · printed under col 159
Al., collectiones. Ita etiam ms. Gaudiival. apud Quesnellum, et tres nostri Vaticani, pro quo perperam alius Vat., collationes.
Others, collectiones. So also the Gaudiival manuscript in Quesnel, and our three Vatican [manuscripts]; for which another Vatican [manuscript] wrongly [has] collationes.
(c) ‹caecitas paganorum› · printed under col 159
Vulgati addunt praepositionem in, quam melius delevimus ex ms. Vallicell. Nonnulli codd. et vulgati ad marginem, super institutionibus suis. Prima editio, in superstitionibus eorum.
The printed editions add the preposition in, which we have done better to delete on the authority of the Vallicelliana manuscript. Some codices, and the printed editions in the margin, super institutionibus suis. The first edition, in superstitionibus eorum.
(d) ‹verae religionis observantia,› · printed under col 159; the note's letter is printed as d without parentheses
Vat. collect. quintae, observantiam reverentur. Cod. Vallicell. pro atteruntur habet conteruntur.
A Vatican [manuscript] of the fifth collection, observantiam reverentur. The Vallicelliana codex has conteruntur for atteruntur.
(e) ‹vocem prophetici spiritus› · printed under col 159
Ita cum potioribus et plerisque nostri codd. editiones anteriores Quesnello, apud quem adderet.
So, with the better and most of our codices, the editions before Quesnel; in whose [edition], adderet.
SYNOPSIS. — Eleemosynam alterum esse lavacrum a peccatis, et opus maximae charitatis.
SYNOPSIS. — That almsgiving is a second washing from sins, and a work of the greatest charity.
SYNOPSIS. — Collectas occasione paganarum superstitionum esse insitutos, a quibus ne pauper quidem excluditur; eleemosyna cruciari daemones; pauperes a collectarum fructu non esse alienos.
SYNOPSIS. — That the collections were instituted on the occasion of pagan superstitions, and not even the poor man is excluded from them; that demons are tormented by almsgiving; that the poor are not strangers to the fruit of the collections.
(f) ‹quantitate. Habeant› · printed under col 160
Addidimus ergo, quod desirabatur, ex duobus msse Vatic. et Lectionario Vallicellano.
We have added ergo, which was lacking, from two Vatican manuscripts and the Vallicelliana Lectionary.
(g) ‹potest tamen› · printed under col 160
Ex iisdem mss. nec non ex editione Antuerp. an. 1583, adjecimus etiam.
From the same manuscripts, and also from the Antwerp edition of the year 1583, we have added etiam.
(h) ‹quae futura credimus,› · printed under col 160
Unus Vat. et prima editio, tamquam gesta.
One Vatican [manuscript] and the first edition, tamquam gesta.
(i) ‹judicii suis inseruit› · printed under col 160
Latinns Latinius, in Bibliotheca sacra et profana, p. 74, corrigendum censuit aequitatem, vel aequalitatem. In cod. Bon., aequalitatem habetur.
Latino Latini, in the Bibliotheca sacra et profana, p. 74, judged that it should be corrected to aequitatem or aequalitatem. In the Bologna codex aequalitatem is found.
(j) ‹quae malis essent› · printed under col 160
Vulgati cum plerisque mss, inferenda. Melior visa est lectio codicis Vallicellani, cum vox timenda voci speranda Leonino more opponatur.
The printed editions, with most manuscripts, inferenda. The reading of the Vallicelliana codex seemed better, since the word timenda is set against the word speranda in Leo's manner.
SYNOPSIS. — I. Evangelica luce gentilitiae superstitionis tenebras repelli, a quibus omnia manant flagitia. — II. Ideo futurum judicium a Christo praedicitur, ut misericordiae largitate peccata redimantur. — III. Collectas institutionis esse apostolicae: occasione paganicae superstitionis esse ordinatas; verecundos maxime pauperes esse sublevandos. — IV. Haereticos prodere Deo imprimis gratum. Manichaeorom dogmata.
SYNOPSIS. — I. That by the light of the Gospel the darkness of heathen superstition, from which all crimes flow, is driven back. — II. That the future judgement is foretold by Christ for this purpose, that sins may be redeemed by the bounty of mercy. — III. That the collections are of apostolic institution; that they were ordained on the occasion of a pagan superstition; that the bashful poor above all are to be relieved. — IV. That to report heretics is especially pleasing to God. The doctrines of the Manichees.
(a) ‹posset. Quisquis› · printed under col 161
Emendavimus ex ms. Vallic. In caeteris nostris codd. et in omnibus editis legebatur: Qaidquid igitur hominum quibuslibet impietatibus Deum laesit, hujus fraude traductum, hujus est nequitiae depravatum.
We have emended from the Vallicellian manuscript. In our other codices and in all the printed editions it read: "Whatever of men, therefore, has offended God by any impieties whatever, [is a thing] led astray by his fraud, depraved by his wickedness."
(b) ‹flagitia impulit, quos› · printed under col 161
In addunt duo codd. collect. 4, et alius collect. 5, et edit. Antuerp. ms. Vallic., in religione suscepit.
Two codices of collection 4, and another of collection 5, and the Antwerp edition add "in"; the Vallicellian manuscript [has] "in religione suscepit" [he received in religion].
(c) ‹oculis divinae› · printed under col 161
Cod. Bon. cum prima editione, districtionis, non male.
The Bon. codex, with the first edition, [reads] "districtionis" [of strictness], not badly.
(d) ‹hoc gratia› · printed under col 161
Vallicell., Salvatoris.
The Vallicellian [codex has] "Salvatoris" [of the Saviour].
(e) ‹societatem pervenire› · printed under col 161
Felicium vocem oppositam voci miserorum substituimus loco vocis fidelium, quatuor mss. et edit. Antuerpiensis auctoritate futili. Pro pervenire legunt aliqui codd., pertinere.
We have substituted the word "felicium" [of the happy], set against the word "miserorum" [of the wretched], in place of the word "fidelium" [of the faithful], on the authority of four manuscripts and the Antwerp edition, it being worthless. For "pervenire" some codices read "pertinere".
(f) ‹sanctarum› · printed under col 161, continued under col 162
Editi cum plerisque mss., collectionum. Melius in Vallicellano, cum vox collationum optime respondeat, et referatur ad eleemosynarum oblationem, de qua post pauca fit mentio. In prima editione habetur, sanctarum collectionum prima collatio; non displicet.
The printed editions with most manuscripts [read] "collectionum". Better in the Vallicellian, since the word "collationum" [contributions] corresponds best and refers to the offering of alms, of which mention is made a little later. In the first edition there is "sanctarum collectionum prima collatio" [the first contribution of the holy collections]; it is not displeasing.
(g) ‹impiorum,› · printed under col 162
Secuti sumus lectionem primae editionis, quam mss. collectionis 3 et Lectionar. Vallicell. confirmant. Aliae editiones, sacratissima a nobis nostrarum, etc. Quesnellus, sacratissime.
We have followed the reading of the first edition, which the manuscripts of collection 3 and the Vallicellian lectionary confirm. Other editions [read] "sacratissima a nobis nostrarum", etc. Quesnel [reads] "sacratissime".
(h) ‹regionum vestrarum› · printed under col 162
Legendum, quinta feria, ut in admonitione diximus; sed nullo codice opitulante, textum immutare noluimus.
One should read "quinta feria" [on the fifth day of the week], as we said in the admonition; but since no codex supports it, we have been unwilling to change the text.
(i) ‹voluntas,› · printed under col 162
Ex Vallicellano et aliis duobus codicibus, nec non ex prima editione inseruimus praepositionem ad, quae commode indicat quod traditur serm. 11, c. 2: Sancta collectio, quae per praesidentium curam necessariis serviret expensis.
From the Vallicellian and two other codices, and also from the first edition, we have inserted the preposition "ad", which aptly indicates what is related in sermon 11, chapter 2: "A holy collection, which through the care of those presiding might serve necessary expenses."
(j) ‹verecundia› · printed under col 162
Prima editio, impedit.
The first edition [reads] "impedit".
(k) ‹et malunt› · printed under col 162
Cod. Vallic., molestia.
The Vallicellian codex [reads] "molestia" [with the trouble].
(l) ‹occulta necessitate› · printed under col 162
Mss. collect. 4 et 5, revelandi.
Manuscripts of collections 4 and 5 [read] "revelandi" [to be disclosed].
(m) ‹Recte› · printed under col 162
Sic Lectionar. Vallicell. et mss. collect. 5, cum Antuerpiensi editione. Alias, enim in egeno.
So the Vallicellian lectionary and the manuscripts of collection 5, with the Antwerp edition. Elsewhere, "enim in egeno".